First, America lost its princess. Then, it lost its sweetheart.
The death of Debbie Reynolds, following Carrie Fisher’s, isn’t fair.
It’s not supposed to be like that — not just for movie fans, but in real
life. Mothers aren’t supposed to outlive their daughters — even if it's
by a day and a half.
But that’s the grim kind of year 2016 has been.
And so Reynolds — the perky star of “Singin’ in the Rain” and innocent
victim in the old, endless Liz Taylor/Eddie Fisher headlines — has
followed Fisher, the sarcastic lead in the “Star Wars” series (and
survivor of endless rehab stories).
The only thing lessening the pain of the cruel one-two punch is
imagining Carrie in some better place far, far away, sardonically
acknowledging it all.
Really, Mom? Seriously? You had to try and upstage me with this, too?
They were a loving mother and daughter, yes, but they were consummate
performers, too — both since they were teens, both ruling different
decades.
Their close, but competitive, relationship inspired Fisher’s novel
“Postcards from the Edge,” the movie adaptation and even a recent
documentary.
Their affection was real, but so was its occasional, slight, get-out-of-my-spotlight edge.
“People used to call her ‘Debbie Reynolds’ daughter,’ ” Reynolds, who
was 84, said once, “now they call me ‘Princess Leia’s mother!’ ”
The smile was as genuine as she could make it, but the sharpness was
still palpable. Of course, their bond went deeper than that, and in ways
mere movie fans can never understand. Because no one else can really
know what it was like to be in the midst of the Fisher-Taylor love
triangle back in the ’50s, a kind of run-through for
Jennifer-Brad-Angelina that played out self-righteously on shocked
movie-mag covers.
The scandal only furthered Taylor’s bad-girl image, but it ruined Eddie
Fisher’s career and helped drive Reynolds into another lousy marriage.
It also gave Carrie Fisher an attitude — and material for years.
“My father was best friends with a man named Michael Todd,” Carrie
Fisher explained once. “Mike Todd was married to Elizabeth Taylor. Mike
Todd died in a plane crash, and my father consoled Elizabeth Taylor with
his penis.” Reading her father’s torrid autobiography, she later
confessed, made her want to “have my DNA fumigated.”
But the jokes came later. At the time, the poor publicity abandoned
Debbie, Carrie and her brother Todd — until Liz Taylor dumped Eddie for
Richard Burton, and a new scandal took its place.
No one can fully know what that mother-daughter experience was like.
Just as no one can quite understand what it was like to be starting your
own movie career (that’s Carrie playing the teen temptress in
“Shampoo”) just as your mom had seen hers begin to wind down (in the
horror schlocker “What’s the Matter With Helen?”)
But what we can all understand, and share, is what these women meant to different generations at different times.
Because if you were a child of the ’50s, Debbie Reynolds was wholesome
optimism personified — cheerfully singing out “Good Morning” in “Singin’
in the Rain,” strumming her guitar as “The Singing Nun” and surviving
even the Titanic as “The Unsinkable Molly Brown.”
And when the movie career ended, the eternally plucky star moved to TV.
When the studios started throwing out their own history, and ours, she
scooped up the memories, and started a museum.
Meanwhile, if you were a ’70s kid, Carrie Fisher, who was 60 when she
died, was feminism made fun — taking sarcastic charge in the first “Star
Wars,” and taking no nonsense from the males around her. True, she
never got a light saber. But she didn’t need one to stand up to Darth
Vader or put Han Solo in his place.
When Jabba the Hutt tried to turn her into a cheap sex symbol, she grabbed those chains back — and used them to strangle him.
Later decades provided new struggles for both women. An aging Reynolds
had to fight to support herself, after her second husband ripped her off
and her industry wrote her off. Fisher battled mental illness,
substance abuse and bad marriages.
It wasn’t fair. They had only wanted to act. They hadn’t set out to be
role models, and their lives were proof that roles were sometimes only
that.
Yet their struggles — Reynolds' middle-aged need to reinvent herself;
Fisher’s fight against loneliness and drugs — mirrored the struggles of
their generations.
If things got confused for them, they had gotten confused for a lot of
us, too. We could identify with the way both ladies fought on, and kept
going, and kept their sense of humor — about themselves, each other, and
their own relationship.
And now console ourselves with knowing that they went out as they would
have liked. Still competing. Still on top. Still together.
Whitty is a longtime movie critic.
No comments:
Post a Comment